I find this to be untrue. I 100% will not date a man who is ripped. So I definitely have a preference.
It shows me many things about said gymbro - first, that he spends way too much time at the gym. Second, that he's probably going to expect me to as well. Third, he's likely ill-prepared for the inevitable old people-ness that is coming for all of us.
So yeah, hard pass.